tool name

close
tool goes here

Smith, Baird still undecided on health care vote

With a climactic vote on health care legislation expected in the House of Representatives late this week, two Democratic members from Washington state – Adam Smith and Brian Baird – remain undecided on how to vote.

Published: 03/16/10 6:36 am | Updated: 03/16/10 10:05 am
0 comments

WASHINGTON – With a climactic vote on health care legislation expected in the House of Representatives late this week, two Democratic members from Washington state – Adam Smith and Brian Baird – remain undecided on how to vote.

Smith voted for an earlier version of the bill. Baird did not.

As House Democratic leaders and the White House scrambled Monday to secure the 216 votes needed to pass health care legislation, Smith said that while there might be a lot of good things in the measure, “I have not made up my mind.”

Baird, who is not seeking re- election, said he needed to see the actual language in the bill and an accompanying reconciliation bill before he would decide.

“Until I am able to read the new proposal and know the costs, I will not decide on how to vote on passage,” Baird said. “To do so would contradict what I have stood for throughout my congressional career.”

Meanwhile, Democratic congressional leaders showed signs of progress Monday in winning anti-abortion Democrats whose votes are pivotal to President Barack Obama’s fiercely contested remake of the health care system.

Obama expressed optimism Congress would approve his call for affordable and nearly universal coverage as he pitched his plan on a trip to Ohio, while Republican Sen. Jim DeMint of South Carolina, among the bill’s sharpest opponents, said he was “less confident” than before that it could be stopped.

“They’d have to be remarkable people not to fall under the kind of pressure they’ll be under,” DeMint said of rank-and-file Democrats.

The pressure was turned up Monday as the House Budget Committee, on a 21-16 vote, took an essential first step toward the House vote, which could come next weekend. Obama and his supporters labored in the capital and on Air Force One.

Rep. Dennis Kucinich, D-Ohio, who flew with Obama, then walked into an Ohio senior citizen center with the chief executive in time to hear a voice from the audience yell out, “Vote yes.”

A smiling Obama turned to the liberal lawmaker and said, “Did you hear that, Dennis?” Then, turning back to the audience, he added, “Go ahead, say that again.”

“Vote yes!” came back the reply.

Kucinich, who said later he remains uncommitted, is one of 37 Democrats currently in the House who voted against Obama’s legislation when it cleared the House last fall.

Baird hinted that the latest version of the bill might be more to his liking.

“The legislation that is currently being discussed in the House of Representatives is far different from the bill I voted on in November 2009,” Baird said in a statement released late Friday. Baird has not been available for an interview despite several requests.

Last year, the House approved its version of the bill by five votes, 220-215, with 39 Democrats opposing the measure. On Christmas Eve, the Senate passed its bill.

The fate of the health care overhaul has been uncertain since a Republican won a special Senate election in Massachusetts, leaving Democrats one vote shy of the 60 needed to overcome filibusters.

Even though the Senate-passed bill was less than popular with House Democrats, their leaders want them to approve it without changes. Then the two chambers would use a reconciliation bill to make changes that House Democrats have insisted on. It will only take 51 votes to get the reconciliation bill through the Senate.

In an interview, Smith said he’d found a “lot of good things” in the Senate bill, including that it was less expensive than the House bill, had better cost containment, was more manageable and didn’t take a major whack out of Medicare Advantage.

But Smith said the changes anticipated in the reconciliation bill could drive up costs.

A leader of moderate Democrats in the House, Smith was among those invited to the White House last week for a session with President Barack Obama.

“It’s possible I vote for the Senate bill and against reconciliation,” Smith said.

Smith said he wasn’t bothered by Republican criticism that Democrats were using parliamentary maneuvers to pass a health care bill.

“We have not rushed this through,” Smith said, adding that the reconciliation process had been used 22 times before, including the vote to pass the tax cuts sought by then President George W. Bush.

Les Blumenthal: 202-383-0008

lblumenthal@mcclatchydc.com

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Similar stories:

  • Payroll tax cut talks adrift on Capitol Hill

  • Payroll tax cut extended as congressional standoff ends

  • House ready to consider insider trading ban

  • House passes incentives for veterans to remain in Alaska

  • Obama urges congressional leaders to extend payroll tax cut

JOIN THE DISCUSSION | Register here

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service. If you have any questions, including why your comment may not be showing immediately after you submit it, be sure to visit the commenting FAQ.

The News Tribune had 72,010 visitors yesterday
South Sound Cars .com
VIEW ALL »

Presented By
Lakewood Ford

2011 Ford Ranger
Silver color, 3,306 miles
$16,496.00

South Sound Homes .com
VIEW ALL »

Homes By
Windermere Real Estate

LUXURY CUSTOMS NOW READY
Four residences with fine upgrades and detail in Historic Steilacoom/new prices!

South Sound Rentals .com
VIEW ALL »

Park 19

You\'ll notice the difference...
from other apartment communities the moment you step on the grounds of Park 19.

TribBits
GridIron Hits 2011/12 - Football Picks
Local prizes sponsored by Korum Puyallup Nissan
Subscribe to The News Tribune
Click Here to Subscribe
GridIron Hits 2011/12 Subscribe to The News Tribune