Horse racings final jewel loses luster when it loses I'll Have Another
BETH HARRIS AND RICHARD ROSENBLATT
NEW YORK – The Triple Crown curse lives. And this time, the horse didn’t even make it to the starting gate.
I’ll Have Another’s bid for the first Triple Crown in 34 years ended stunningly Friday when the chestnut colt was retired on the eve of the Belmont Stakes with an injury to his left-front tendon.
“I’m afraid history is going to have to wait for another day,” said J. Paul Reddam, the colt’s owner.
I’ll Have Another, which won the Kentucky Derby and the Preakness Stakes with stirring stretch drives, was the 4-5 early favorite to win the Belmont and become the 12th Triple Crown winner and first since Affirmed in 1978.
Instead, he’ll make one final trip to the track with his jockey Mario Gutierrez to lead the other Belmont horses during today’s post parade – no longer a prelude to greatness, but merely a wistful farewell.
“He’ll be my hero forever,” a somber Gutierrez said. “What I’ll Have Another did for me is so amazing. He brought happiness to my life.”
Always the longest and toughest of the Triple Crown events, the 11/2-mile Belmont was instantly reduced to being just another big race.
The favorite’s role fell to Dullahan, which ran third in the Derby and had been second in the morning line for the Belmont. He was made the 9-5 early choice.
Trainer Doug O’Neill said I’ll Have Another was being retired because he developed swelling in his left-front tendon that was the beginning of tendinitis.
“This is extremely tough for all of us. It’s far from tragic, but it’s extremely disappointing,” he said.
O’Neill’s brother, Dennis, said it was hard to tell anything was wrong just by looking at the horse.
“He looks great. He’s sound. He went great this morning. He looks super (but) you just can’t take a chance,” he said. “He’s too valuable of a horse, and we love him to death like all of them. You wouldn’t run a horse if you think something might happen.”
The scratch comes a day before an estimated 100,000 fans were expected to converge on the track in hopes of seeing, at long last, a Triple Crown winner – a champion who would help resurrect a struggling racing industry.
I’ll Have Another joined 11 other horses since Affirmed who won the Derby and the Preakness, but were unable to complete a Triple Crown sweep in the Belmont, extending the longest gap between Triple winners to 35 years. The colt also became the third winner of the first two legs unable to run in the finale; Burgoo King in 1932 and Bold Venture in 1936 were the others.
“It’s like completely letting the air out of a balloon,” said Ken McPeek, who trains Belmont contenders Atigun and Unstoppable U.
Said Dale Romans, who trains Dullahan: “This was going to be a special race, one of the biggest races of our time. I’d rather have him in there. It would have been something special to beat him.”
Doug O’Neill said he first noticed something might be wrong with the colt Thursday, hours after his usual morning gallop.
“We prayed he kind of hit himself and that it was a little bit of skin irritation,” he told a horde of reporters gathered outside the detention barn at Belmont Park.
O’Neill had called an audible Friday and taken his horse out to gallop at 5:30 a.m., three hours earlier than he had been working out in the days leading up to the race. He wanted to avoid the congestion created by all the Belmont horses going to the track at the same time.
“I thought he looked great on the track,” he said, “and then cooling out, you could tell that swelling was back, and at that point I didn’t feel very good.”
A veterinarian confirmed the diagnosis and suggested that O’Neill give the colt three to six months off before resuming training. But O’Neill said he and his brother, along with Reddam and his wife, were unanimous in deciding to retire the colt, the winner of four consecutive Grade 1 races, starting with the Santa Anita Derby in April.
“I really thought he was going to run off (Saturday) and really show something,” Reddam said. “So we were all a bit shocked, but we have to do what’s best for the horse.”
Dr. Larry Bramlage, on-call veterinarian for the Belmont, said it wouldn’t hurt I’ll Have Another to walk on the track “but would be a concern at a mile-and-a-half at full speed.”
He compared the problem to an Achilles tendon injury, which usually keeps a person off his feet for six weeks.
“This one to the horse is nowhere near that severity,” he said, “but it takes the same amount of time to rehab it.”
Bramlage said it probably would take a year for the colt to recover. He added that a tendon in a racehorse is “more highly evolved” than anything in a human.
O’Neill said I’ll Have Another would return to his home base at Hollywood Park in Inglewood, Calif., in the next few days.
The injury underlines the fragility of these 1,100-pound thoroughbreds, racing at speeds up to 40 mph. Other Triple Crown bids were foiled in odd ways, too.
Big Brown was pulled up at the top of the stretch in the 2008 Belmont, mysteriously failing to finish the race; War Emblem nearly fell to his knees coming out of the gate in 2002 and wound up eighth; Charismatic broke two bones in his left front leg with a quarter mile to go, but still finished third in 1999; Spectacular Bid stepped on a safety pin in his stall before the 1979 race and finished third; and Tim Tam ended up second in 1958 after running the final quarter-mile with a broken bone in his right front ankle.
“You only get one chance to do this,” said four-time Belmont winner D. Wayne Lukas, who trains Belmont Stakes contender Optimizer. “From the standpoint of a purist, it’s a blow.”
After talking to the media, O’Neill led I’ll Have Another out of the detention barn and walked him down a path toward the barn where the colt had stayed most of the time he had been at the track. Since Wednesday, all the Belmont Stakes horses were housed in the same barn with 24-hour surveillance; racing officials said it was to ensure the race was run fairly.
“Some people have asked did the detention barn have anything to do with this. Absolutely not. Just a freakish thing,” O’Neill said. “I’ve been hoping and praying he would stay injury-free, and it didn’t happen.”
HISTORIC IN A DIFFERENT WAY
I’ll Have Another is just the third horse in racing history – and the first in 76 years – to not start the Belmont Stakes after winning the first two legs of the Triple Crown. The others:
1932: Burgoo King (leg injury)
1936: Bold Venture (leg injury)