tool name

close
tool goes here

For-profit treatment facilities need state oversight

An unfortunate situation unfolding in the Seattle suburb of Normandy Park offers a cautionary tale to other cities. What’s happening there could very easily happen elsewhere.

Published: Sept. 28, 2012 at 12:05 a.m. PDT
0 comments

An unfortunate situation unfolding in the Seattle suburb of Normandy Park offers a cautionary tale to other cities. What’s happening there could very easily happen elsewhere.

According to reporting by the Seattle Times, a for-profit company in Normandy Park that claims to provide mental health treatment is one of a growing number of such organizations that have found a sweet spot that allows them to avoid state regulatory oversight.

Earlier this year, California-based Hanbleceya opened a clinic in Normandy Park and either purchased or rented five nearby homes as housing for its clients – people suffering from an array of serious mental illness, drug addiction or other conditions. It charges clients up to $100,000 a year for room and treatment.

Because the treatment is provided at the clinic, not at the homes, Hanbleceya maintains that they are not residential treatment facilities – thus they don’t need to be licensed and regulated by the state Department of Health.

Besides maintaining unregulated boarding homes in residential neighborhoods, Hanbleceya has been accused of neglecting its vulnerable clients. According to critics, when clients act out, punishment can include being kicked out of housing and forced to fend for themselves on the street. At the same time, their families continue to pay for their care and are told not to respond if the client tries to make contact.

One client interviewed by the Times – a mentally ill young man with substance abuse issues – was dropped off in downtown Seattle with little money and no ID. Temperatures dropped into the 30s, and he had only sandals and the clothes on his back. He spent weeks on the street – yet his parents were not informed and were still charged for care and treatment he wasn’t receiving.

“It’s a miracle he didn’t kill himself or someone else,” said his father.

If there’s a gap in state law that allows this sort of “treatment” to go unregulated, then it must be addressed. In at least one other state, Texas, neglect at a boarding facility led to the deaths of four men in a fire. That state is now expected to pass legislation next month to regulate these homes.

Until the state acts, cities should take preemptive measures against such unregulated activity. They should examine their zoning codes and determine if they are vulnerable to an organization like Hanbleceya moving in.

It’s unfortunate that the state’s shortage of psychiatric facilities – and general reluctance to fund mental health care – have resulted in this sort of for-profit company stepping in to fill a vacuum. The state needs to exert more oversight – by requiring staff training and adequate supervision, for starters – in order to improve safety for clients and neighbors.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION | Register here

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service. If you have any questions, including why your comment may not be showing immediately after you submit it, be sure to visit the commenting FAQ.

CONTESTS

Similar stories

  • Pierce County's mental health provider scrutinized

    Suppose a deal that promised more for less turned out to be less for more. Pierce County leaders are beginning to wonder whether that's the takeaway from a 4-year-old experiment that handed the local mental health system to an out-of-state corporation.

  • Optum gives quality mental health care to more people

    Last Sunday, The News Tribune presented a very critical view of OptumHealth Pierce RSN, headlined “Mental health provider scrutinized.”

  • No vacancy, no excuse for Western State to deny care

    No vacancy is no excuse for denying treatment to the mentally ill. That idea, the core of a legal ruling issued Wednesday by Pierce County Superior Court Commissioner Craig Adams, throws an inconvenient wrench into the gears of the state's ailing mental-health system and forces a public debate over a practice known as psychiatric boarding.

  • Revolving door leaves one patient, entire community at risk

    Feb. 27: Four sets of straps bind patient B.P. to the gurney. She can’t feel them; swimming in a medicated dream, she snores like an old baby. Parked in a narrow hallway at Western State Hospital, she’s about to have her day in court – again.

  • State’s broken mental health system is creating tragedies

    Editor’s note: This is an expanded version of a letter to the editor that appears on The News Tribune’s letters blog: blog.thenewstribune. com/letters. Recent articles in the News Tribune have dramatically highlighted the revolving-door policy that my family and I are all too familiar with. The mental health system in Washington is in crisis.