tool name

close
tool goes here

War is the best – and most grim – teacher of geography

Geography teachers tend to put their students to sleep. And no wonder. Until you’ve been there, who cares where the Rhine River runs? Or what kind of winters they have in North Korea? Or which ocean is home to Iwo Jima? And what’s an Iwo Jima anyway?

Published: Oct. 6, 2012 at 12:05 a.m. PDT
0 comments

Geography teachers tend to put their students to sleep. And no wonder. Until you’ve been there, who cares where the Rhine River runs? Or what kind of winters they have in North Korea? Or which ocean is home to Iwo Jima? And what’s an Iwo Jima anyway?

All three places were once boring to most third-grade geography students. However, all three of those places eventually became lethally interesting. In fact, the day would come when former third-graders would suffer and die in all three locations.

War is a horrible geography teacher. It knows how to make the topic not just interesting but also so terrifying that the grieving families of the dead will never forget where an unlucky loved one met his end.

There is a lot of memorizing involved in ordinary geography classes. But Professor War gives us sudden knowledge of the names and locations of killing grounds. The Rhine, Korea and Iwo Jima are burned for life into our minds.

To the warriors who were there, the weather in Korea is not just a memory but frostbite on the brain. The combatants in that war were threatened almost as much by a harsh Korean winter as by their armed adversary.

And how can anyone here or in Japan forget Iwo Jima? All losses are painful but some are more numerous. A few thousand U.S. and NATO troops have died in Afghanistan over the long years of that conflict. That many died in hours on Iwo Jima in the Pacific.

Speaking of Afghanistan, it’s hard to believe now that hardly anyone knew anything about that once-obscure place in all the vast nowhere of the world until the old Soviet Union and the United States took turns going to war there.

That affected journalism as well as third-graders. Afghanistan used to be such a cipher that hardly anyone could tell you where on God’s green Earth that forlorn country was to be found. Even the toughest history teachers would cut a kid a little slack for not knowing much about Afghanistan.

In journalism, something else was being taught – “Afghanistanism.” That was a term in newspaper editorial writing that referred to the habits of a timid newspaper. If you write a critical editorial about the mayor of your town, you may bump into him at the grocery store and he will glare at you – or maybe do worse to your paper if he is a merchant and is one of your advertisers.

The word Afghanistanism was coined to describe how some twitchy newspapers felt obliged to write limp editorials and avoid angry mayors. Nervous newspapers chose safe topics, writing tiresome lectures about how the leader of Afghanistan (or some other obscure place) has become a rotten bully. An editor doesn’t have to worry about the leader of Afghanistan canceling any advertising.

Of course, you don’t hear the term anymore today because Afghanistan has become so infamous that a third-grader could remember it.

Former CBS anchorman Walter Cronkite once conceded that much of the news is negative by definition. Television stations and newspapers don’t do stories on the cats that don’t get caught in a tree.

So if people in small countries that are off the beaten path suddenly make it into international news, look out!

I live in such a place, in the state of Idaho. We have yet to go to war against other states, so media centers like New York City, Washington, D.C., and Atlanta hardly ever mention us.

And we want to keep it that way because, if we get any mention at all in the major media, it’s usually a forest fire.

Bill Hall can be contacted at wilberth@cableone.net or at 1012 Prospect Ave., Lewiston, ID 83501.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION | Register here

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service. If you have any questions, including why your comment may not be showing immediately after you submit it, be sure to visit the commenting FAQ.

CONTESTS

Similar stories

  • Boise State literacy program educates, inspires, expands

    Boise State’s Summer Literacy Center Academy has become so popular with children and their families that the center has expanded it to a year-round program on Saturday mornings.

  • TRAVEL: Museum tells tales of terror, bravery

    NEW ORLEANS — Marine Lt. Leonard Isaaks Jr. was killed on Feb. 20, 1945, during the battle for the Japanese island Iwo Jima. All you really need to know about his death is contained in the painstakingly printed letter found on his body:

  • State Senate, House divided on education issues

    Republicans in the state Senate want to revive a handful of controversial education-reform measures during upcoming budget negotiations, including giving principals veto authority over teacher transfers, assigning letter grades to schools, and intervening when students can’t read well by third grade.

  • Third-grader goes medieval on Tacoma public officials

    In many ways, Louden Miller is a typical 8-year-old boy. He plays with his dog, Mackey. He ignores his sister’s cat, Cupcake. He loves fishing with his grandfather.

  • Operation Write Home connects troops, families

    Sandy Allnock had a stash of unsent cards she created for special occasions, and she thought she could find a group that would forward them to overseas service members. The Federal Way woman could not find an organization that would connect her with soldiers in Iraq or Afghanistan, so she created her own. "It was an accident, but it was a meant-to-be accident," she said.