tool name

close
tool goes here

Franklin County commissioners want to know if lawsuit will stop doughnut hole annexation

Published: Jan. 10, 2013 at 12:00 a.m. PSTUpdated: Jan. 10, 2013 at 7:15 a.m. PST
0 comments
Residents who live in the Franklin County 'doughnut hole' surrounded by the city of Pasco say they want to keep their country lifestyle -- including bigger lots and the ability to raise livestock. (KAI-HUEI YAU/Tri-City Herald)

Franklin County commissioners on Wednesday asked whether an ongoing lawsuit over Pasco's recent annexation of part of the "doughnut hole" area leaves the annexation in limbo.

Commissioner Brad Peck asked Ryan Verhulp, the deputy prosecutor who serves as the county's attorney, if the annexation went into effect Jan. 1 -- as Pasco intended -- or if the lawsuit means it's still just pending.

"I don't know which one trumps the other," Peck said.

Verhulp didn't immediately have an answer.

"I'll get you a written opinion," he said.

But Roger Lenk, a leader within the Citizens For Lifestyle Preservation group that sued seeking to block the annexation, told commissioners at the Wednesday meeting that the group's position is that the litigation leaves everything up in the air.

The doughnut hole area generally is south of Argent Road between Road 100 on the west and Road 44 to the east and Sylvester and Court streets to the south, and has been earmarked for future Pasco growth since the '90s.

The city council voted 5-2 on Oct. 29 to annex part of the doughnut hole between Road 52 and Road 68, south of a Franklin County Irrigation District canal.

The vote was intended to block efforts by Citizens For Lifestyle Preservation to incorporate the doughnut hole as a new city called Riverview. Incorporation proponents gathered enough petition signatures to put the question to a vote, but state law requires that the new city have at least 3,000 residents, and the October annexation vote pulled about 1,400 of the doughnut hole's 4,000 residents into Pasco effective Jan. 1.

But Lenk said a judge could yet overturn the annexation, leaving the incorporation petition in play.

"The residents of Riverview will continue to fight annexation," Lenk said. "It is our position that the incorporation petition remains valid as long as we have litigation."

That leaves commissioners in an awkward position, since they're required to have a public hearing on the incorporation petition. They voted in December to postpone the hearing until Jan. 23.

But the lawsuit still could be going when that date comes. A hearing scheduled in the suit on Monday was postponed, and the city is seeking summary judgment -- basically a ruling from the judge that the facts are in the city's favor and the case shouldn't go to trial.

The city already lost a motion to dismiss the case in December.

Also Wednesday:

w Commissioners voted unanimously to add up to $150,000 to the 2012 budget for TRAC to account for additional revenues and expenses from unexpected business the Pasco event center saw during the year.

TRAC Manager Troy Woody told commissioners the center likely wouldn't need the full $150,000, but that all of December's bills haven't come in yet.

He added that year-end projections show TRAC about $300,000 in the negative instead of the $400,000 that had been projected.

Franklin County and Pasco subsidize losses at the event center.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION | Register here

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service. If you have any questions, including why your comment may not be showing immediately after you submit it, be sure to visit the commenting FAQ.

CONTESTS

Similar stories

  • Franklin County commissioners could make doughnut hole decision soon

    Franklin County commissioners could decide Monday whether to send to the ballot the petition to incorporate the "doughnut hole" area as a new city called Riverview.

    Or they could delay a decision until a lawsuit is resolved that seeks to overturn Pasco's annexation of part of the area proposed for incorporation.

    Commission Chairman Rick Miller said delaying might make sense because the lawsuit still is pending. Commissioners already have postponed the matter three times while everyone waits for an outcome.

  • Franklin County commissioners deny petition for new city

    Franklin County commissioners Monday denied a petition signed by hundreds of west Pasco "doughnut hole" residents to vote on incorporating their own city.

    The commissioners cited the city of Pasco's annexation of part of the area when making their decision, as the proposed city no longer fits boundaries the petitioners submitted, nor would it have enough residents.

    "I don't know if the board has any other choice but to recognize that annexation has taken place," said Commissioner Brad Peck.

  • 'Doughnut hole' hearing set for today in Pasco

    Franklin County Commissioners are scheduled to have a public hearing today on the proposed incorporation of the Riverview area.

    Riverview also is known as the "doughnut hole" and is a piece of Franklin County surrounded by Pasco.

    Pasco annexed part of the area effective Jan. 1, reducing the population below the threshold to allow the area to incorporate.

  • Roger Lenk files new lawsuits against Pasco

    Doughnut hole resident Roger Lenk this week filed two new lawsuits against Pasco alleging the city violated provisions of the state's Public Records Act.

    One lawsuit claims Lenk submitted a document request related to the proposed regional aquatic center on Jan. 23, but received no response from the city.

    Lenk said in court documents that he instead received a response from the Benton Franklin Council of Governments saying that the agency would fulfill the request because it is handling administrative functions for the Tri-Cities Regional Public Facilities District, the public agency overseeing development of the aquatic center.

  • Herald staff takes a look back at 2012

    Herald staffers chose the alleged embezzlement of millions of dollars by former Franklin County employee Dennis Huston as the top local news story of 2012.