tool name

close
tool goes here

State appeals Boise parking garage denial

Published: Feb. 12, 2013 at 2:39 p.m. PSTUpdated: Feb. 12, 2013 at 3:59 p.m. PST
0 comments

LKV Architects’ appeal letter called the Boise Design Review Committee’s denial of the state’s application “inappropriate and unacceptable.”

At a January hearing, committee members said the proposed garage’s architecture is inconsistent with the surrounding area and its landscaping design didn’t do enough to hide it from neighbors’ sight.

According to LKV's letter, the design of the garage structure and landscaping was meant to address concerns the committee raised.

The Capitol Mall Parking Garage, mandated by the Idaho Legislature, would provide 580 parking spots just north of the Capitol on the 600 block of Washington Street. Money to pay for it would come from bonds issued by the Idaho State Building Authority.

In denying the state’s application, the committee went against city staff, which recommended approval, as long as the state met six conditions. Those conditions included elimination of stalls designated for compact cars, the placement of trees around the outside of the parking garage and outdoor parking lot, and the inclusion of at least 64 bicycle spaces and 13 spaces accessible to disabled drivers or passengers.

The state, through LKV’s letter, said it was willing to meet those conditions.

Idaho Public Works Project Manager Martin Santoyo said he expects the city’s Planning and Zoning Commission to take up the matter in March.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION | Register here

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service. If you have any questions, including why your comment may not be showing immediately after you submit it, be sure to visit the commenting FAQ.

CONTESTS

Similar stories

  • Boise denies state's parking garage appeal

    The state of Idaho failed to show Boise’s Design Review Committee erred when it rejected the state’s plans for a parking garage north of the Capitol, Planning and Zoning commissioners found Monday.

    According to the Planning and Zoning commissioners,“the decision of the Design Review Committee was not inconsistent with the purpose and objectives of the (city's applicable) ordinance, does not place an unreasonable economic hardship on the applicant, does not interfere with the design integrity of the proposal, does not discriminate based upon the use of the property, does not include improper motive, and does not include any unwarranted restrictions.”

    At a January hearing, members of the Design Review Committee said the proposed garage’s architecture is inconsistent with the surrounding area, and its landscaping, as planned, wouldn’t do enough to hide the structure from neighbors’ sight. The committee has accepted the garage’s proposed height while rejecting the design of the building and materials the

  • Updates from the Idaho Legislature

    Legislation aimed at toughening penalties for attacks on doctors, nurses and care providers failed on an 18-17 vote in the Senate when Lt. Gov. Brad Little broke a tie.

  • Idaho seeks to trump Boise's rejection of Downtown parking garage

    Now what are they up to? Senate Assistant Majority Leader Chuck Winder - who ran for Boise mayor in 2003 - pitched a bill to exempt the state from the city's building-approval process for projects on the state-owned Capitol Mall property.

  • State: Garage vote was conflict of interest

    A Boise Design Review Committee said it was a bad design, not sour grapes, that caused him to vote against a state application for a Downtown parking garage. A state official said the vote looks bad.

  • Boise City Council approves state parking garage

    Instead of denying the state’s application for a six-story, 580-space garage, members of the city’s Design Review Committee and Planning and Zoning Commission should have worked with the state and its architect to resolve disagreements, City Council President Maryanne Jordan said Tuesday.

    Failure to work through those disagreements caused an unnecessarily long and contentious approval process, Jordan said.

    In January, the Design Review Committee denied the state’s application on the grounds that its design wasn’t in keeping with the area surrounding the state’s chosen lot northwest of the corner of Washington and 6th streets.