Simpson hands off its pulp mill with honor

The News TribuneMarch 7, 2014 

The Simpson Tacoma Kraft paper mill has been bought by a Georgia-based company, RockTenn.


Corks won’t pop off champagne bottles when a responsible company sells off a pulp mill with a tawdry past and potentially troublesome future.

But you can hope for the best. That’s how we’re dealing with Simpson Lumber Company’s decision to transfer its Tideflats paper mill to RockTenn, a Georgia outfit that’s a bit of a stranger in this corner of the country. Simpson will hang on to its sawmill at the site.

RockTenn looks like a promising newcomer, the kind that knocks on the neighbors’ doors with loaves of fresh-baked bread and offers to take their garbage cans out when they’re gone. RockTenn certainly knows the business: It runs 24 paper mills, most located in the southeastern United States.

The company intends to keep all the employees of the Tacoma pulp mill, a good sign. Its leaders say they have healthy relationships with unionized and non-unionized workers at the plants RockTenn already owns.

But an immense chemical plant in the middle of a densely populated metropolitan area is problematic by definition. The mill near the mouth of Foss Waterway once did enormous damage to the environment and to Tacoma’s reputation. If a future owner let it slide, it could again become a major liability to the area.

Simpson bought the plant in 1985. A look back shows how extraordinary a neighbor the company has been.

Built in 1928, the mill severely polluted the adjacent mudflats and waterway, turning its surroundings into a toxic dead zone. It was also the chief contributor to the noxious, sulfurous odors that routinely drifted out of the Tideflats. The smell prompted endless jokes about the “Tacoma Aroma”; it reinforced the city’s image as a decaying post-industrial wasteland.

Simpson spent hundreds of millions of dollars changing all that. High points:

 • It replaced stinking boilers, eventually eliminating the odor as part of a quarter-billion-dollar plant overhaul.

 • It came up with a creative plan to clean up the mudflats, which again became habitat for young salmon and other creatures.

 • It steeply cut its water consumption, steam plumes and emissions of airborne particles.

 • It greatly expanded its cardboard recycling and built a renewable-fueled 55-megawatt power plant to run the mill.

What if some other company had managed the operation as a cash cow, avoiding investment and battling environmental regulations whenever possible? It’s too easy to imagine a continuing stink, or the whole plant abandoned to blight the Tideflats as a towering junkyard.

We don’t expect anything of the sort from RockTenn, which has promised an initial investment of $60 million to keep the plant up to date. One reason to trust RockTenn: Simpson does. No company that builds such an environmental legacy wants to see it get squandered by the heirs.

The News Tribune is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service