Army Staff Sgt. Robert Bales has asked an Army court for a special hearing to explore evidence that his massacre of 16 Afghan civilians may have been tied to a controversial malaria drug given to troops that is known to cause hallucinations, anxiety and paranoia.
During a hearing Tuesday at Fort Belvoir, Virginia, a subject matter expert for Bales, former Army public health physician Dr. Remington Nevin, submitted affidavits arguing that Bales likely experienced hallucinations and psychosis related to either taking mefloquine, also known by the brand name Lariam, in Afghanistan or previously in Iraq.
The prescription was not considered during the investigation and his legal team is using this in a request for the U.S. Army Court of Criminal Appeals to review Bales’ life sentence without parole in the killings that took place on March 11, 2012 in Kandahar province.
Mefloquine is a malaria treatment medication that was commonly used by the U.S. military as a prophylactic in malaria endemic regions, taken once a week by troops. It has been controversial since its commercial introduction in 1989, as it is known to cause neurological and vestibular problems in a small percentage of users.
Concerns inside the Defense Department began surfacing in 2002 following a string of violent deaths and suicides among soldiers and military family members at Fort Bragg, N.C. In 2004, a federal investigation found that 11 troops taking the medication experienced debilitating vertigo.
In 2009, the Defense Department issued a policy listing it as a last-choice preventive, to be used only in areas where strains are resistant to other medications.
And in 2012 and 2016, several case studies were published of troops developing brain damage as a result of taking the drug.
Shortly after Bales murdered the Afghan civilians on March 11, 2012, retired Army psychiatrist Col. Elspeth Cameron Ritchie raised questions as to whether Bales had been taking mefloquine during his deployment or on his previous three trips to Iraq.
The next month, in April 2012, the Food and Drug Administration received notification from Roche, the maker of the brand-name version of mefloquine, that it had received a report from an anonymous pharmacist that a patient taking the medication had developed homicidal behavior that “led to the homicide killing of 17 Afghans.” (Initial reports cited that 17, not 16, villagers had been killed.)
“It was reported that the patient was suffering from traumatic brain injury and was administered mefloquine in direct contradiction to U.S. military rules that mefloquine should not be given to soldiers who had suffered traumatic brain injury due to its propensity to cross blood-brain barriers inciting psychotic, homicidal or suicidal behavior,” the report stated.
Bales had sustained a traumatic brain injury during his last deployment to Iraq in 2009.
The FDA disclosed the adverse report in 2013 as Bales was being sentenced, having pleaded guilty in exchange for dropping the death penalty. The lead prosecutor in the case, now-retired Army Lt. Col. Jay Morse, told McClatchy that the document, which was referenced in news stories, was not known to the prosecution as evidence and there was nothing in Bales’ health records on mefloquine prescriptions.
A full bottle of doxycyline, another malaria preventive, was found in his possession after the murders.
“There is zero evidence that Bales was on mefloquine,” Morse said.
The lack of evidence or record, however, is not surprising. In January 2012, then Assistant Secretary of Defense for Health Affairs Dr. Jonathan Woodson issued a memo noting that some deployed service members were issued mefloquine without it being recorded in their medical records.
“In addition, not all individuals have been provided the required mefloquine medication guide and wallet information card. It is incumbent upon us to ensure our service members are appropriately screened and informed about the medicines they are taking and we must accurately record their prescriptions in their medical record,” Woodson wrote.
The FDA in 2013 placed a black box warning on mefloquine, to alert patients of the drug’s potential neurological and psychiatric side effects.
In his clemency request in 2014, Bales cited post-traumatic stress disorder, his brain injury, alcohol and steroid use while deployed, as well as his reliance on sleeping pills and steroids he took as possible contributing factors.
He also spoke of guilt, fear and the desire to protect his fellow soldiers all as factors.
“I still don’t believe that the PTSD, TBI, alcohol, steroids and sleeping pills were the only factors in my actions on March 11, 2012. I believe there is much more,” he wrote.
Morse, who attended Tuesday’s hearing as an observer, said the three-judge panel focused most of their questions on the mefloquine defense, but also considered affidavits that charged that some of the witnesses had ties to bomb-making and family members had ties to the Taliban. They now will consider whether Bales’ team presented enough information to grant an evidentiary hearing and a possible new sentencing hearing.
“Let’s assume all this is true, but you still have nine women or children were killed. Bales knew this and he pleaded guilty,” Morse said. “I’m confident that justice was done in this case, no doubt in my mind.”