JobsCarsHomesRentalsPlace an ad »
         E-mail          Print          Text
CHARLES KRAUTHAMMER: Bait them with universal coverage, then switch


Similar Stories

Similar stories:
Published: 08/28/0912:05 am | Updated: 08/31/09 9:17 am
Comments (0)

WASHINGTON – Obamacare Version 1.0 is dead. The 1,000-page monstrosity that emerged in various editions from Congress was done in by widespread national revulsion not just at its expense and intrusiveness but at the mendacity with which it is being sold.

You don’t need a Ph.D. to see that the promise to expand coverage and reduce costs is a crude deception, or that cutting $500 billion from Medicare without affecting care is a fiction.

But there is an exit strategy. And a politically clever one, if the Democrats are smart enough to seize it.

 • Forget the public option. Whatever the merits, and they are few, it is political poison. It dies by the Liasson Logic, the unassailable observation by NPR’s Mara Liasson that there are no liberal Democrats who will lose their seats if the public option is left out, while there are many moderate Democrats who could lose their seats if the public option is included.

 • Jettison any reference to end-of-life counseling. People see (correctly) such Medicare-paid advice as subtle encouragement to voluntarily refuse treatment. People don’t want government involvement in a process they consider the private province of patient, family and doctor. The Senate is already dropping it. The House must follow.

 • Soft-pedal the idea of government committees determining “best practices.” President Obama’s Federal Coordinating Council for Comparative Effectiveness Research was sold as simply government helping doctors choose the best treatments. But there are dozens of medical journal review articles that do just that.

The real purpose of FCCCERs is ultimately to establish official criteria for denying reimbursement to less favored (because presumably less effective) treatments – precisely the triage done by the NICE committee in Britain, the Orwellian body that once blocked access to a certain expensive anti-blindness drug until you went blind in one eye.

 • More generally, abandon the whole idea of Obamacare as cost-cutting. True, it was Obama’s original rationale for creating a whole new entitlement at a time of a sinking economy and a bankrupt Treasury. But, as many universal health care liberals complain, selling pain is poor salesmanship.

 • Promise nothing but pleasure – for now. Make health insurance universal and permanently protected. Tear up the existing bills and write a clean one – Obamacare 2.0 – promulgating draconian health-insurance regulation that prohibits (a) denying coverage for pre-existing conditions, (b) dropping coverage if the client gets sick, and (c) capping insurance company reimbursement.

What’s not to like? If you have insurance, you’ll never lose it. Nor will your children ever be denied coverage for pre-existing conditions.

The regulated insurance companies will get two things in return. Government will impose an individual mandate that will force the purchase of health insurance on the millions of healthy young people who today forgo it. And government will subsidize all the others who are too poor to buy health insurance. The result? Two enormous new revenue streams created by government for the insurance companies.

And here’s what makes it so politically seductive: The end result is the liberal dream of universal and guaranteed coverage – but without overt nationalization. It is all done through private insurance companies. Ostensibly private. They will, in reality, have been turned into government utilities. No longer able to control whom they can enroll, whom they can drop and how much they can limit their own liability, they will live off government largesse – subsidized premiums from the poor; forced premiums from the young and healthy.

It’s the perfect finesse – government health care by proxy. And because it’s proxy, and because it will guarantee access to (supposedly) private health insurance – something that enjoys considerable Republican support – it will pass with wide bipartisan backing and give Obama a resounding political victory.

Isn’t there a catch? Of course there is. This scheme is the ultimate bait-and-switch. The pleasure comes now, the pain later. Government-subsidized universal and virtually unlimited coverage will vastly compound already out-of-control government spending on health care. The financial and budgetary consequences will be catastrophic.

However, they will not appear immediately. And when they do, the only solution will be rationing. That’s when the liberals will give the FCCCER regulatory power and give you end-of-life counseling.

But by then, resistance will be feeble. Why? Because at that point the only remaining option will be to give up the benefits we will have become accustomed to. Once granted, guaranteed universal health care is not relinquished.

Look at Canada. Look at Britain. They got hooked; now they ration. So will we.

Charles Krauthammer is a Pulitzer Prize-winning Washington Post columnist. He can be reached at letters@charleskrauthammer.com.

 

Comments

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service.

Comments are displayed newest first. If you would like to read a thread from beginning to end, select "Oldest first" from the drop down menu.
Presented By
Previous Ad Next Ad
0/0
Homes By
Previous Ad Next Ad
0/0
A Reasonable Awning, Inc. A Single Man AAA Travel American Memorial Anahuac Anderson Appliance Aqua Rec's Swimmin' Hole & Fireplace Shop At Your Service Plumbing AT&T B&I Coin Shop Banner Bank Bergman Draper & Frockt BetterThanMedicare.com Big 5 Sporting Goods Bloom Blue Mouse Theatre Bodies The Exhibition Boyle's Foreign Car Repair Broadway Center For The Performing Arts Bruce Titus Automotive Group Builders Service Company Cabela's Centralia Outlets Charles Schwab CI Shenanigans City of Tacoma Classy Chassis Coast Home Improvement, Inc. Columbia Bank Corvette & High Performance Meet Crazy Heart Deja Vu Dr. Dan Baldwin, D.C. Early Bird Swap Meet Emerald Queen Hotel & Casino Farmers Insurance Group Franciscan Health System Franciscan Medical Group Franke Tobey Jones Building & Garden Apartments Fred Meyer Friesenburgers From Paris With Love Frontier Bank Galaxy Theatres Gene Pankey Motor Company Harbor Audiology & Hearing Services, Inc. Harnish Buick / Pontiac / GMC Health Fair Hearthside Manor Homestead Restaurant HomeStreet Bank Johnny's Dock Restaurant & Marina JP Morgan Chase Bank Kantor Diamond Company Katherine E. Crabill D.D.S. Kenneth P. Ring, DDS Lakewood Family Medicine & Chiropractic Lakewood Ford La-Z-Boy Furniture Galleries Les Schwab Lovers Macy's Memory Wellness Program Muckleshoot Casino MultiCare Neuroscience Center of Washington MultiCare Pulmonary Specialists Narrows Glen Navy Federal Credit Union New Covenant Pentecostal Tabernacle New Life Spinal Decompression Center New Tacoma Cemeteries & Funeral Home Northern Fish Products Co. Northwest Chapter of Paralyzed Veterans of America Northwest Charity Donation Service Northwest Mini Oscar's Restaurant & Lounge Pacific Northwest Ballet / The Sleeping Beauty Pacific Northwest Polish Pottery Party World Pfizer, Inc. / Lipitor Pierce County Pierce County Library System Pioneer Place Puget Sound Health Partners Pulmonary Consultants, PLLC Puyallup Fairgrounds / Collectible Auto Swap Meet Radiant Research Rainier Pacific Bank Red Canoe Credit Union Red Wind Casino Regence Roof Therapy, Inc. Russ Dunmire Sears Smith Alling Lane, P.S. South Tacoma Mazda Sprinker Recreation Center St. Francis Hospital St. Joseph Medical Center / South Sound Gamma Knife St. Mary's Catholic Church Star Ice & Fuel State Farm Insurance Sterling Savings Bank Tacoma Athletic Commission / Annual Golden Gloves Championship Tacoma Boys / H & L Produce Tacoma Church of Christ Tacoma Dream Home Raffle Tacoma Public Utilities Tacoma Women's Specialists The Grand Cinema The Liberty Theater The Lutheran Church of St. Paul The Young Victoria Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion / Pre-owned at Stadium T-Mobile USA, Inc. Tooth Fairy Toyota Truckcity CB, EV and Solar Van Lierop Bulb Farm Vargus & Associates, Inc. Video Only Washington Council of the Blind We The People, P.S. Law Office Weir's Appliance Wendover Resorts Wiggins Mantels & Woodworks Inc. Window World of Seattle Yarn & Fiber Marketplace Yelm Cinemas Star Ice & Fuel State Farm Insurance Sterling Savings Bank Tacoma Athletic Commission / Annual Golden Gloves Championship Tacoma Boys / H & L Produce Tacoma Church of Christ Tacoma Dream Home Raffle Tacoma Public Utilities Tacoma Women's Specialists The Grand Cinema The Liberty Theater The Lutheran Church of St. Paul The Young Victoria Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion / Pre-owned at Stadium T-Mobile USA, Inc. Tooth Fairy Toyota Truckcity CB, EV and Solar Van Lierop Bulb Farm Vargus & Associates, Inc. Video Only Washington Council of the Blind We The People, P.S. Law Office Weir's Appliance Wendover Resorts Wiggins Mantels & Woodworks Inc. Window World of Seattle Yarn & Fiber Marketplace Yelm Cinemas Star Ice & Fuel State Farm Insurance Sterling Savings Bank Tacoma Athletic Commission / Annual Golden Gloves Championship Tacoma Boys / H & L Produce Tacoma Church of Christ Tacoma Dream Home Raffle Tacoma Public Utilities Tacoma Women's Specialists The Grand Cinema The Liberty Theater The Lutheran Church of St. Paul The Young Victoria Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion / Pre-owned at Stadium T-Mobile USA, Inc. Tooth Fairy Toyota Truckcity CB, EV and Solar Van Lierop Bulb Farm Vargus & Associates, Inc. Video Only Washington Council of the Blind We The People, P.S. Law Office Weir's Appliance Wendover Resorts Wiggins Mantels & Woodworks Inc. Window World of Seattle Yarn & Fiber Marketplace Yelm Cinemas Star Ice & Fuel State Farm Insurance Sterling Savings Bank Tacoma Athletic Commission / Annual Golden Gloves Championship Tacoma Boys / H & L Produce Tacoma Church of Christ Tacoma Dream Home Raffle Tacoma Public Utilities Tacoma Women's Specialists The Grand Cinema The Liberty Theater The Lutheran Church of St. Paul The Young Victoria Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion / Pre-owned at Stadium T-Mobile USA, Inc. Tooth Fairy Toyota Truckcity CB, EV and Solar Van Lierop Bulb Farm Vargus & Associates, Inc. Video Only Washington Council of the Blind We The People, P.S. Law Office Weir's Appliance Wendover Resorts Wiggins Mantels & Woodworks Inc. Window World of Seattle Yarn & Fiber Marketplace Yelm Cinemas
Front page PDF