As this primary season has gone along, a strange sensation has come over me: I miss Barack Obama.
Now, obviously I disagree with a lot of Obama’s policy decisions. I’ve been disappointed by aspects of his presidency. I hope the next presidency is a philosophic departure.
But during the course of this campaign, it feels as if there has been a decline in behavioral standards across the board. Many of the traits of character and leadership that Obama possesses, and that maybe we have taken too much for granted, have suddenly gone missing or are in short supply.
The first and most important of these is basic integrity. The Obama administration has been remarkably scandal-free. Think of the way Iran-Contra or the Lewinsky scandal swallowed years from Reagan and Clinton.
We’ve had very little of that from Obama. He and his staff have generally behaved with basic rectitude.
Hillary Clinton is constantly having to hold these defensive press conferences when she is trying to explain away some vaguely shady shortcut she has taken, or decision she has made, but Obama hasn’t had to do that.
He and his wife have not only displayed superior integrity, they have mostly attracted and hired people with high personal standards.
There are all sorts of unsightly characters floating around politics, including in the Clinton camp and in Gov. Chris Christie’s administration. This sort has been blocked from team Obama.
Second, a sense of basic humanity. Donald Trump has spent much of this campaign vowing to block Muslim immigration. You can only say that if you treat Muslim-Americans as an abstraction. Obama, meanwhile, went to a mosque, looked into people’s eyes and gave a wonderful speech reasserting their place as Americans.
He has exuded this basic care and respect for the dignity of others time and time again. Let us put it this way: Imagine if Barack and Michelle Obama joined the board of a charity you’re involved in. You’d be happy to have such people in your community. Could you say that comfortably about Ted Cruz? The quality of a president’s humanity flows out in the unexpected but important moments.
Third, a soundness in his decision-making process.
Over the years, I have spoken to many members of this administration who were disappointed the president didn’t take their advice. But the disappointed staffers almost always felt their views were considered in depth.
Obama’s basic approach is to promote his values as much as he can within the limits of the situation. Bernie Sanders, by contrast, has been so blinded by his values that the reality of the situation does not seem to penetrate his mind.
Take health care. Passing Obamacare was a mighty lift that led to two gigantic midterm election defeats.
As Megan McArdle pointed out in her “Bloomberg View” column, Obamacare took coverage away from only a minority of Americans. Sanderscare would take away employer coverage from tens of millions of satisfied customers, destroy the health-insurance business and levy massive new tax hikes. This is epic social disruption.
To think you could pass Sanderscare through a polarized Washington and in a country deeply suspicious of government is to live in intellectual fairyland.
Obama may have been too cautious, especially in the Middle East, but at least he is able to grasp the reality of the situation.
Fourth, grace under pressure. I happen to find it charming that Marco Rubio gets nervous on the big occasions — that he grabs for the bottle of water, breaks out in a sweat and went robotic in the last debate. It shows Rubio is a normal person. I happen to think overconfidence is one of Obama’s great flaws.
But a president has to maintain equipoise under enormous pressure. Obama has done that, especially amid the financial crisis. After Saturday night, this is an open question about Rubio.
Fifth, a resilient sense of optimism. To hear Sanders or Trump, Cruz and Ben Carson campaign is to wallow in the pornography of pessimism, to conclude this country is on the verge of complete collapse.
That’s simply not true. We have problems, but they are less serious than those faced by just about any other nation on Earth.
People are motivated to make wise choices more by hope and opportunity than by fear, cynicism, hatred and despair. Unlike many candidates, Obama has not appealed to those passions.
No, Obama hasn’t been temperamentally perfect. Too often he has been disdainful, aloof, resentful and insular. But there is a tone of ugliness creeping across the world, as democracies retreat, as tribalism mounts, as suspiciousness and authoritarianism take center stage.
Obama radiates an ethos of integrity, humanity, good manners and elegance that I’m beginning to miss, and I suspect we will all miss a bit, regardless of who replaces him.
David Brooks is a New York Times columnist.