JobsCarsHomesRentalsPlace an ad »
         E-mail          Print          Text
Public would benefit most from federal shield law

Similar Stories

Similar stories:
Published: 04/19/08 1:00 am
Comments (0)

A new front in the attack on reporters’ ability to aggressively seek the truth could make journalists pine for the days when all they needed fear for refusing to give up a confidential source was jail.

A federal judge has ordered a former USA Today reporter to pay $5,000 for each day she doesn’t cough up the names of sources she may or may not have consulted for stories about a 2001 anthrax mailing controversy.

The kicker is that the money must come from Toni Locy’s own pocket. The judge has ordered her to accept help from no one – not her family or her former employer or the journalism students who wanted to hold a bake sale for her.

If the order holds, Locy is facing personal financial ruin. Journalists on the whole are a public-minded (not to mention stubborn) sort, but they have their limits. For some, avoiding bankruptcy could trump the sanctity of promises made to sources.

The public has a big stake in ensuring that the government cannot exploit that breaking point. Compelling journalists to break confidences undermines their ability to protect vulnerable sources from retribution and to uncover information the public needs to know.

In Washington, the Legislature passed a shield law last year to prevent judges from forcing reporters into the role of private investigators. Forty-eight other states plus the District of Columbia have similar protections. But the defense is not complete until Congress acts.

A proposed federal shield law passed the House last fall, but has yet to clear the Senate. This week, the three members of the Senate running for president all voiced support for the bill, boosting compromise legislation under negotiation. Members of Congress are working to narrow the scope of the privilege to answer concerns that it could extend to non-journalists or compromise classified information.

It’s about time the federal government followed the states’ lead and acknowledged that journalists’ ability to shine the halogen searchlight of public attention on corruption, injustice or official misfeasance is vital to a healthy democracy. The proposed federal shield law deserves passage – not to protect reporters, but to ensure that the public gets news it might otherwise never see.

 

Comments

JOIN THE DISCUSSION

We welcome comments. Please keep them civil, short and to the point. ALL CAPS, spam, obscene, profane, abusive and off topic comments will be deleted. Repeat offenders will be blocked. Thanks for taking part — and abiding by these simple rules. A thorough explanation of rules of conduct can be found in our Terms of Service.

Comments are displayed newest first. If you would like to read a thread from beginning to end, select "Oldest first" from the drop down menu.
Presented By
Previous Ad Next Ad
0/0
Homes By
Previous Ad Next Ad
0/0
A Single Man AAA Travel American Memorial Anderson Appliance Annual Tacoma Home & Garden Show At Your Service Plumbing AT&T Bergman Draper & Frockt Big 5 Sporting Goods Blue Mouse Theatre Boyle's Foreign Car Repair Broadway Center For the Performing Arts Brownie Morrison Charles Schwab Chevrolet Classy Chassis Coast Home Improvement, Inc. Comcast Corvette & High Performance Meet Crazy Heart CreditGuard CSC Brands, LP Deja Vu Dr. Thomas Young NMD, DC Early Bird Swap Meet EB5 Facial Cream Farmers Insurance Group Franciscan Health System Franciscan Medical Group Frank Tobey Jones Senior University Fred Meyer Galaxy Theatres Gene Pankey Motor Company Harbor Lights Harkness Furniture Homestead Restaurant Item House Warehouse Jane Thompson Russell Cancer Care Center Johnny's Dock Restaurant & Marina JP Morgan Chase Bank Kantor Diamond Company Kenneth P. Ring, DDS Lakewood Family Medicine & Chiropractic Lakewood Ford Les Schwab Macy's Memory Wellness Program Muckleshoot Casino MultiCare Orthopedics & Sports Medicine Museum of Glass Narrows Glen New Tacoma Cemeteries & Funeral Home Northwest Charity Donation Service Northwest Flower & Garden Show O'Loughlin Trade Shows / Washington Sportmen's Show Oreck Clean Home Store Pacific Northwest Ballet / The Sleeping Beauty Pacific Northwest Shop Party World Pfizer, Inc. / Lipitor Port of Tacoma U.S.A. Prostalex Plus Pulmonary Consultants, PLLC Puyallup Fairgrounds / Collectible Auto Swap Meet Radiant Research Red Canoe Credit Union Red Wind Casino Roof Therapy, Inc. Rush Custom Homes, Inc. Russ Dunmire Sears Seattle Boat Show Smith Alling Lane, P.S. Sonus Sound Credit Union South Tacoma Mazda Sprint Star Ice & Fuel State Farm Insurance Sterling Savings Bank Subaru of Puyallup Tacoma Athletic Commission / Annual Golden Gloves Championship Tacoma Boys / H & L Produce Tacoma Dream Home Raffle Tacoma/Valley Radiation Oncology Centers The Grand Cinema The Imperial Dragon Restaurant The Orthopaedic Center The Young Victoria Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion Titus-Will Ford / Toyota / Scion / Pre-owned at Stadium T-Mobile USA, Inc. To Save a Life Tooth Fairy Toyota Truckcity CB, EV and Solar University of Puget Sound Van Lierop Bulb Farm Vargus & Associates, Inc. Verizon Wireless Video Only Walmart Washington Sportsmen's Show Washington State Department of Corrections Watson's Greenhouse & Nursery Wendover Resorts Western Air Defense Sector Yelm Cinemas Video Only Walmart Washington Sportsmen's Show Washington State Department of Corrections Watson's Greenhouse & Nursery Wendover Resorts Western Air Defense Sector Yelm Cinemas Video Only Walmart Washington Sportsmen's Show Washington State Department of Corrections Watson's Greenhouse & Nursery Wendover Resorts Western Air Defense Sector Yelm Cinemas Video Only Walmart Washington Sportsmen's Show Washington State Department of Corrections Watson's Greenhouse & Nursery Wendover Resorts Western Air Defense Sector Yelm Cinemas
Front page PDF