The legal fight is so old that the governor whose re-election was at the heart of the case has left office, the defendant is no longer the campaign heavyweight it once was, and the lead plaintiff is dead.
But the case lives on after a decision Thursday by the state Supreme Court.
The 8-to-1 ruling sends the case of Utter v. Building Industry Association of Washington back to a King County court for more proceedings.
The case involves Republican Dino Rossi’s 2008 rematch with Gov. Chris Gregoire, which Democrat Gregoire won. Two retired Supreme Court justices, Faith Ireland and the late Robert Utter, accused the builders’ association of wrongdoing in its campaigning for Rossi.
Premium content for only $0.99
For the most comprehensive local coverage, subscribe today.
After a state investigation, an arm of BIAW paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in a 2010 settlement.
An appeals court found the investigation precluded the lawsuit from going forward, but the state Supreme Court reversed that decision. State law allows for citizens to sue when state attorneys don’t, the high court said.
“The statute is obviously based on the notion that the government may be wrong, and then it is up to citizens to expose the violation,” Justice Sheryl Gordon McCloud wrote for the majority.
The Supreme Court also found the plaintiffs presented enough evidence to raise real questions about whether BIAW should have registered as a political committee.
Groups have to register as political committees and disclose finances to the state if campaigning is one of their primary purposes, even if it’s not “ the primary purpose,” the court declared, a point that could have implications in future campaigns.
Fatigue with the case showed up in Chief Justice Barbara Madsen’s lone dissent, which said the state investigation long ago addressed the essence of the legal complaint.
“It is time for the parties to move on,” Madsen wrote.