Mariners Insider Blog

Padres 14, Mariners 6: Paxton routed in return to big leagues

It was a rough Wednesday night for lefty James Paxton and the Mariners.
It was a rough Wednesday night for lefty James Paxton and the Mariners. AP

SAN DIEGO — No gentle way to put this. James Paxton’s return Wednesday night to the big leagues was disaster. A crushing disaster. And a wasted opportunity in an 14-6 roll-over loss to a reeling opponent.

The Mariners recalled Paxton from Triple-A Tacoma to start against the San Diego Padres after a strained right calf forced Felix Hernandez to the disabled list.

The Padres had lost 12 of their previous 15 games, including 16-4 pummeling Tuesday by the Mariners at Safeco Field, and were blasted publicly earlier in day by their executive chairman as "miserable failures."

Robinson Cano then hit a three-run homer in the first inning that provided Paxton with an early cushion. Everything was set up for an easy night, and then everything went wrong.

Paxton gave up six runs in the first inning…six runs to an opponent that ranked 28th in scoring among the 30 clubs.

"It’s disappointing," he said. "I was just too amped up and too fired up for it. I thought after the first inning, I settled down a little bit and started making some better pitches.

"But unfortunately, they had already gotten their wheels turning."

Paxton fueled that first-inning mess with a costly throwing error on a play that could have gotten him out of the inning with a 3-1 lead.

And it was downhill from there.

Paxton (0-1) threw 103 pitches in just 3 2/3 innings while allowing eight runs and 10 hits. The Mariners then turned to Joel Peralta, whose struggles continued when he gave up four more runs in 1 1/3 innings.

Then it was Steve Johnson’s turn to get roughed up for three runs in his only inning. Johnson had not allowed a run over 10 1/3 innings over his nine previous appearances.

What a train wreck.

It begs the question: Does Paxton get another chance in five days? Or do the Mariners look for an alternative?

"We’ll see where it goes from here," manager Scott Servais said. "The game just got over. Those decisions are organizational decisions. I would certainly like to give him another opportunity."

The Padres hit four homers, including two by Alexei Ramirez, who entered the game with one. Ramirez also had five RBIs. Wil Myers and Adam Rosales also hit homers.

John Jay had four hits. Myers and Yangervis Solarte each had three. The Padres finished with 19.

"They came out and swung the bats," Cano said, "and did the same thing to us that we did to them (on Tuesday). We beat them at our place by (almost) the same score. They came back today.

"I think they got mad, maybe."

The game turned in a wild first inning that, for the Mariners, started with such promise.

Nori Aoki opened the game by working back from an 0-2 hole for a nine-pitch walk against Padres starter Christian Friedrich. Franklin Gutierrez followed with a single before Cano turned on a first-pitch fastball.

A 3-0 lead.

Friedrich (2-1) had yielded just three runs combined in his three previous starts. The Mariners had a chance for more when they loaded the bases with one out, but Luis Sardinas popped out, and Paxton took a third strike.

Three runs wasn’t enough.

The Padres began their comeback when Myers launched a one-out homer, on the last of four straight fastballs, over the right-field wall.

Matt Kemp and Solarte followed with singles, which put runners at first and third with one out and set up the decisive moment.

Melvin Upton hit a potential double-play grounder back to the mound, but Paxton threw the ball into center field.

"I was just too amped up and going way too fast," Paxton said. "I didn’t get my feet set to throw the ball, and then I just tried to do too much. That first inning got away from me."

One run scored on the error, making it 3-2, and the Padres still had runners at first and third with one out. After Upton stole second base without a throw, Derek Norris tied the game with a sacrifice fly to center.

San Diego took the lead on Ramirez’s RBI single to right before Adam Rosales hit a two-run homer to left. What had been a three-run lead was now a three-run deficit.

A long night was just beginning.

PLAY OF THE GAME: James Paxton had a chance to escape the first inning with a 3-1 lead if he’d executed a basic PFP play. (That’s pitchers’ fielding practice, and clubs hold repeated drills in spring training.)

The Padres had runners at first and third with one out when Melvin Upton hit an easy one-hopper back to the mound. It should have been an inning-ending double play.

Instead, Paxton threw the ball well wide of second baseman Robinson Cano and into center field. One run scored on that error, and San Diego scored four more runs before the inning ended.

PLUS: Robinson Cano’s homer in the first inning extended his streak of reaching base at least once to 30 games, which is the longest current streak in the majors…Kyle Seager had three hits and raised his average to .284…Nick Vincent pitched a one-two-three inning with two strikeouts.

MINUS: The end could be nearing for veteran reliever Joel Peralta, who gave up three runs in 1 1/3 innings. His ERA is up to 5.40 after giving up 10 runs and 16 hits in his last nine innings…Dae-Ho Lee opened the third inning by one-hopping a drive off the left-field wall. Melvin Upton played the carom perfectly, and Lee threw on the brakes between first and second. But he couldn’t get back safely.

STAT PACK: The Padres’ 14 runs were, by far, the most allowed this season by the Mariners. The previous high was nine by the Angels on May 14 in a 9-7 loss…San Diego’s 19 hits were also a season-worst for the Mariners’ staff. The previous high was 14 on April 11 in a 7-3 loss to Texas

QUOTABLE: "You’ve got to give them credit for the way they were swinging the bat," Robinson Cano said. "(James) Paxton was throwing 98 (mph). It’s tough. Even lefties were able to get hits.

"We got beat. We didn’t let them beat us."

Bob Dutton: @TNT_Mariners