Mariners Insider Blog

White Sox 7, Mariners 6: Bullpen lets three-run lead slip away

Catcher Mike Zunino conferred Thursday with pitcher James Paxton during Chicago’s three-run first inning.
Catcher Mike Zunino conferred Thursday with pitcher James Paxton during Chicago’s three-run first inning. AP

Whether through heavy usage or the law of averages, the Mariners’ potent bullpen, which fueled their recent surge, is showing signs of slippage.

The Wolfpack coughed up a three-run lead Thursday in a 7-6 walk-off loss to the Chicago White Sox at U.S. Cellular Field.

The end came against Nick Vincent (3-4) in the ninth inning after Adam Eaton lofted a leadoff single into left field. Eaton moved to second on Tim Anderson’s sacrifice bunt.

An intentional walk to Jose Abreu set up the desired force plays, but Todd Frazier, who tied the game with a two-run single in the seventh inning, pulled a game-winning single into left field.

"Todd Frazier," manager Scott Servais noted with shrug, "was 0-for-4 with four strikeouts against Nick Vincent."

Right match-up. Wrong result.

This makes three straight losses for the Mariners and four in five games after winning 14 of their previous 18 and climbing back into postseason contention.

As for the bullpen, this was just the latest stumble.

The relief corps squandered a three-run lead in the ninth inning last Sunday in a 7-6 loss to Milwaukee and let two games get away last week when the Mariners settled for a split in a four-game series at Anaheim.

"Those guys have been very good," Servais said, "and it was lined up good. We had the error in the seventh. Then a walk. Those things will bite you.

"You give teams more than three outs in an inning, and they usually come back to get you. It did tonight."

Chicago closer David Robertson (4-2) got the victory after pitching a scoreless ninth inning. You might remember the Mariners spanked him for four ninth-inning runs on July 18 at Safeco Field in rallying for a 4-3 victory.

OK, let’s reset: The Mariners built a 6-3 lead, which starter James Paxton handed to the bullpen to start the sixth inning. Tom Wilhelmsen worked an easy sixth in his first outing since Sunday’s collapse against the Brewers.

But Chicago pulled even by scoring three runs in the seventh against Arquimedes Caminero and Steve Cishek. An error by shortstop Ketel Marte started the White Sox rolling.

"It changed a lot in the last two seconds," Marte said. I was charging in on it. I did what I can do, and that’s part of the game. It took a funny bounce, but it’s part of the game. You can’t do anything about it."

After Marte booted J.B. Shuck’s leadoff grounder, left fielder Nori Aoki made a diving catch on Tyler Saladino’s sinking liner.

It proved a temporary reprieve.

Caminero walked Adam Eaton before Anderson atoned for his error in the Mariners’ three-run sixth by driving a double over Leonys Martin’s head in center that hopped the wall.

The White Sox were back to within 6-4 and had runners at second and third with one out. The Mariners replaced Caminero with Cishek, who struck out Jose Abreu with a sweeping slider.

That got the game to Frazier, who had struck out three times against Paxton. This time he grounded a two-run single through the left side. The White Sox were back even at 6-6.

All three runs were unearned because of Marte’s error.

It stayed 6-6 until the ninth.

Afterward, Vincent and Caminero each parked themselves in front of video machines to study their performances.

"I thought we were in a good spot tonight, up three," Servais said. "We just weren’t able hold them down."

And as an added penalty for not beating Chicago starter Anthony Ranaudo, who sports a 9.61 ERA, the Mariners now face All-Star lefties Chris Sale and Jose Quintana in the next two games.

The Mariners broke a 3-3 tie in the sixth inning by cashing a gift.

Robinson Cano followed his game-tying homer in the fourth inning by lining a one-out single to left. Nelson Cruz followed with a sharp hopper back to the mound that Ranaudo deflected.

Anderson grabbed the carom but made a wild throw to first. The scoring was an infield single for Cruz, and a throwing error on Anderson for allowing Cano to take third.

Adam Lind flicked a tie-breaking single into right for a 4-3 lead.

When Ranaudo then loaded the bases by walking Mike Zunino, the White Sox went to the bullpen for their only lefty reliever, Dan Jennings, to face Martin.

The strategy didn’t work. Martin lined Jennings’ first pitch into center for a two-run single. The Mariners led 6-3. All six runs were charged to Ranaudo, who escaped with a no-decision.

PLAY OF THE GAME: Left fielder Nori Aoki made a diving catch on a sinking liner by Tyler Saladino for the first out in the seventh inning with a runner at first. The Mariners led 6-3 and, at the time, it seemed a key play.

The White Sox challenged the call, believing that Aoki trapped the ball. But the replay review let the call stand.

"I knew I caught it," he said. "But after looking at the replay, I was thinking, `Well, maybe it slipped out.’ But, thankfully, it didn’t."

Reliever Arquimedes Caminero couldn’t cash the reprieve. He walked the next batter before giving up an RBI double. Steve Cishek replaced Caminero and allowed a two-run single.

PLUS: Robinson Cano was 2-for-4 for his fourth straight multi-hit game… Nori Aoki has reached base safely at least once in 20 straight games against the White Sox…Nelson Cruz went 1-for-3 with a sacrifice fly and has reached base safely in 23 straight road games.

MINUS: Shawn O’Malley is 0-for-8 with three strikeouts in two games as a replacement at third base for injured Kyle Seager…reliever Arquimedes has allowed runs in four of his last six outings after not allowing a run in his first five outings after arriving in an Aug. 6 trade from Pittsburgh…Steve Cishek suffered his seventh blown save in 34 save/hold situations.

STAT PACK: The Mariners are 6-8 when tied after eight innings.

QUOTABLE: Mariners starter James Paxton provided one positive in his first start since suffering a bruised left elbow Aug. 9 on a line drive.

"No pain; no tightness," he said. "That was good. No issues there."

Paxton gave up three runs in the first inning on five singles and needed 31 pitches to get three outs. Four of the singles were ground balls, but Paxton declined to shrug that off.

"That’s the way baseball goes sometimes," he said. "They’re going to find holes. I was missing my spots, though. So that’s what happens."

SHORT HOPS: The loss kept the Mariners three games behind Baltimore in the race for the American League’s final wild-card berth with 35 games remaining. But the loss permitted Detroit to move past them in the wild-card standings. The Tigers are two games behind the Orioles…the Mariners’ postseason chances are also down to 26 percent in the latest computer simulations by

Bob Dutton: @TNT_Mariners