Local

Man arrested on suspicion of stealing $1,000 in trading cards in Puyallup

A photo of the trading cards that were stolen from the South Hill Mall Target on Feb. 5, 2026. The value of these cards adds up to over $1,000.
A photo of the trading cards that were stolen from the South Hill Mall Target on Feb. 5, 2026. The value of these cards adds up to over $1,000. Puyallup Police Department
Key Takeaways
Key Takeaways

AI-generated summary reviewed by our newsroom.

Read our AI Policy.


  • Suspect detained in Target parking lot after officers found drug paraphernalia.
  • Search warrant recovered over $1,000 in stolen Magic, Pokémon and sports cards.
  • Man charged with third‑degree theft, possession of stolen property and drugs.

A man has been arrested for stealing hundreds of dollars’ worth of trading cards.

A Feb. 12 Facebook post from the Puyallup Police Department said officers found a man slumped over in the passenger seat of a vehicle in the Target parking lot at the South Hill Mall. Kevin Gill, spokesperson for the police department, told The News Tribune the incident happened on Feb. 5

“Officers arrived and began checking on the passenger and investigating the vehicle,” the post said. “During the investigation, drug paraphernalia was observed in plain view.”

While officers were searching the vehicle, the registered owner of the vehicle approached them, the post said.

“Officers noticed bulky items protruding from his clothing and detained him for further investigation. He was found to be in possession of multiple packages of trading cards and admitted to stealing them from Target prior to law enforcement contact,” the post said. “He was arrested and transported to jail for theft.”

The officers released the passenger at the scene, the post said.

Later, officers obtained a search warrant for the vehicle and allegedly found a collection of stolen trading cards.

“During the search, officers located over $1,000 worth of suspected stolen Magic cards, Pokémon cards, and sports trading cards,” the post said. “Fentanyl and methamphetamine were also located.”

Gill told The News Tribune in an email that the man is facing charges of third-degree theft, possession of stolen property and unlawful drug possession.

“Looks like he really took ‘Gotta catch ’em all’ a little too seriously,” the post said.

Isabela Lund
The News Tribune
Isabela Lund is the Lead Breaking News Reporter at The News Tribune. She previously covered the greater Puyallup area as the East Pierce County reporter. Before joining The News Tribune in February 2025, she served as the digital content manager at KDRV NewsWatch 12 in Medford, Oregon, and as a reporter for the Stanwood Camano News. She grew up in Kitsap County and graduated from Western Washington University in 2022 with a degree in journalism.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER