Tacoma News Tribune Logo

Washington Supreme Court orders new trial for cop killer’s driver | Tacoma News Tribune

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Customer Service
    • About Us
    • Buy Photos and Pages
    • Contact Us
    • Plus
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Newsletters
    • Newspaper in Education
    • Subscribe
    • Subscriber Services
    • Archives

    • News
    • Crime
    • Databases
    • Education
    • Government & Politics
    • Local News
    • Nation & World
    • Military
    • Traffic
    • Watchdog
    • Weather
    • Blogs & Columns
    • Matt Driscoll
    • Sports
    • College
    • High School
    • Mariners
    • Preps Stats
    • Seahawks
    • Sounders
    • Tacoma Rainiers
    • UW Huskies
    • Blogs & Columns
    • Dave Boling
    • Huskies Insider Blog
    • John McGrath
    • Mariners Insider Blog
    • Seahawks Insider Blog
    • Sounders Insider Blog
    • Politics
    • Business
    • Consumers
    • People in Business
    • New Businesses
    • Port of Tacoma
    • Real Estate
    • Opinion
    • Cartoons
    • Editorials
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Op-Ed
    • Opinion Columns
    • Submit a Letter
    • Living
    • Fitness
    • Food & Drink
    • Home & Garden
    • Religion
    • Entertainment
    • Arts & Culture
    • Comics
    • Puzzles & Games
    • Events Calendar
    • Horoscopes
    • Movies
    • TNT Diner
    • Outdoors
    • Fishing
  • Obituaries

    • The Olympian
    • The Peninsula Gateway
    • The Puyallup Herald
    • Northwest Guardian
    • NIE
    • KIRO7

  • Classifieds
  • Place An Ad
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Mobile & Apps

Crime

Washington Supreme Court orders new trial for cop killer’s driver

By Adam Lynn - Staff writer

    ORDER REPRINT →

January 15, 2015 11:10 AM

Over and over during closing arguments in the aggravated murder trial of Dorcus D. Allen, deputy prosecutor Stephen Penner told jurors Allen “should have known” that his friend and employer, Maurice Clemmons, intended to kill four Lakewood police officers on Nov. 29, 2009.

On Thursday, the Washington state Supreme Court ruled Penner should have known better.

In a 9-0 decision, the state’s high court reversed Allen’s convictions, saying Penner misstated the law in his closing arguments by telling jurors they could convict Allen for what he should have known instead of for what he did know about Clemmons’ plans that Sunday.

“The sheer amount of instances where the prosecuting attorney misstated the law heavily indicates that Allen was prejudiced,” Justice Mary Fairhurst wrote for the court. “The jury was required to find that Allen actually knew Clemmons would murder the four officers. Absent this finding, Allen’s conviction cannot stand.”

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The News Tribune

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

The high court returned the case to Pierce County for a new trial.

Prosecutor Mark Lindquist said Allen would be retried.

“As the getaway driver, Allen knew Maurice Clemmons’s plan,” Lindquist said. “This is what the jury found and the court of appeals affirmed their verdict.

“The deputy prosecutor should have phrased his argument more artfully so it was not open to misinterpretation, but it was the evidence that convicted Allen, not the deputy prosecutor’s words.

“I’m sorry the families and the community have to endure another trial. Sometimes the pursuit of justice can be a long and arduous path, but I’m confident we will get there.”

Prosecutors in 2010 charged Allen, also known as Darcus Allen, with four counts of aggravated first-degree murder in the wake of the murders of Sgt. Mark Renninger and officers Tina Griswold, Ronald Owens and Gregory Richards.

Clemmons walked into a Parkland coffee shop and gunned down the four officers as they gathered that morning to discuss their upcoming work day. He was angry with police and had made threats to kill officers and school children in the days leading up to the attack.

A Seattle police officer later shot Clemmons dead as authorities searched two counties for him.

Prosecutors alleged Allen served as his driver the day of the massacre, dropping him off near the coffee shop and then waiting at a nearby car wash to pick him up and drive him away.

They contended Allen knew his boss’ plan all along and therefore was an accomplice.

Allen denied knowing Clemmons’ intentions, despite having seen him make threats against police and brandish a gun in days before the shooting.

Allen’s knowledge of Clemmons’ plans was a key part of the prosecution’s case, and Penner, who tried the case with former deputy prosecutor Phil Sorensen, hammered at that point during his closing argument, at one point telling jurors:

“... really, the question in the case is did he know or should he have known? Did he know or would a reasonable person have known? Well, did he know? Should he have known?”

Allen’s defense attorneys, Peter Mazzone and Mary K. High, objected during Penner’s argument, saying he was misstating the law by intimating their client could be convicted for what he should have known.

Judge Frederick Fleming, now retired, overruled their objections, ruling that Penner’s comments were argument, not evidence, and that jurors should consult the written jury instructions for the proper statement of the law.

The jury convicted Allen, and he was sentenced to more than 400 years in prison.

The state ultimately conceded during the appeals process that Penner “misstated the standard upon which the jury could find Allen had actual knowledge.”

The question then became whether Allen was prejudiced by that mistake.

The high court said yes.

It was telling, Fairhurst wrote in the opinion, that jurors sent out a question during their deliberations that asked, “If someone ‘should have known,’ does that make them an accomplice?”

“This question indicates that the jury was unsure whether it could convict Allen using the incorrect ‘should have known’ standard,” she wrote. “It is possible that the jury believed Allen did not know Clemmons would commit murder but nevertheless convicted him because he ‘should have known,’ which is the wrong standard.”

Related stories from Tacoma News Tribune

crime

Mixed success for prosecutors in Lakewood police killings

January 15, 2015 12:08 PM

  Comments  

Videos

Tim Eyman under investigation in theft of chair from Lacey Office Depot

Tacoma gang member accused of whipping girlfriend for 14 hours appears in court

View More Video

Trending Stories

New Beefy’s Burgers opening on 6th Ave in Tacoma

February 18, 2019 11:00 AM

$30 million in budget cuts coming to Tacoma schools next year. Public asked to share thoughts

February 19, 2019 01:03 PM

Full list of Washington state boys and girls high school regional basketball pairings

February 19, 2019 11:32 AM

1 killed, 1 injured when minivan crashes head-on into semi in Fife

February 19, 2019 08:06 AM

After eating meth, Bonney Lake man’s bizarre behavior forced a plane to land, records say

February 19, 2019 10:19 AM
Local display advertising by PaperG

Read Next

Crime

Man accused of shooting ex-wife outside Lakewood motel told her, ‘You made me do this’

By Stacia Glenn

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 20, 2019 09:47 AM

A man suspected of shooting his ex-wife up to six times outside a Lakewood motel on Friday night has been charged with attempted first-degree murder. He is not in custody.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The News Tribune

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE CRIME

‘There were 11 shots. That’s troubling.’ Man sentenced for killing his cousin

Crime

‘There were 11 shots. That’s troubling.’ Man sentenced for killing his cousin

February 20, 2019 09:16 AM
Eyman lawyers say Office Depot chair removal was accident, but he faces theft charge

Crime

Eyman lawyers say Office Depot chair removal was accident, but he faces theft charge

February 19, 2019 04:00 PM
4th suspected gang member arrested in connection with shooting death outside Lakewood club

Crime

4th suspected gang member arrested in connection with shooting death outside Lakewood club

February 19, 2019 09:23 AM

Crime

After eating meth, Bonney Lake man’s bizarre behavior forced a plane to land, records say

February 19, 2019 10:19 AM

Crime

Dad accused of beating 11-year-old girl with belt, golf club for taking extra food

February 18, 2019 09:39 AM
Sex offender registrations in Pierce County

Crime

Sex offender registrations in Pierce County

February 17, 2019 12:00 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Tacoma News Tribune App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Rewards
  • Pay Your Bill
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Photo Store
  • Archives
Advertising
  • Information
  • Place a Classified
  • Local Deals
  • Place an Obituary
  • Today's Circulars
  • Special Sections
Copyright
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story